Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry

Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry - welcome to our blog Techno Live, now we will discuss information about the Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry, our admins on this blog has been around to collect information you are looking for so that we usakan to display complete information for you, and in this blog, you can also search for other information, ok please continue reading may be easily understood:

This is about : Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry
And this article : Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry
Article confusion, Article donut, Article Football, Article hook 'em horns, Article infringement, Article lanham act, Article longhorn, Article registration, Article trademark, Article unfair competition, Article university of texas,

You can also see our article on:


Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry

Donut Taco Palace in Austin, Texas, is famous for their ‘Longhorns donuts’. These donuts are modelled after the Hook ‘em Horns hand gesture which is made in support of the University of Texas’ Longhorns American football team. These donuts of allegiance satisfied the sweet tooth of many Longhorns fans until last month, when the University of Texas became aware of the situation. They sent a cease and desist letter to the owner of the shop, Angel Feng, citing trademark infringement.

The University of Texas, referring to the donuts, stated that,

“…UT is understandably concerned about your use of the LONGHORN Marks in this manner…We trust that, now that these rights have been brought to your attention you will take the appropriate steps to discontinue sales of the ‘Longhorn Donuts’ and refrain from any other uses of the University’s marks.”

The University has a trademarkin the word ‘Longhorns’.  It is unclear whether the Hook ‘em Horns gesture is a registered character mark as the trademark registry recordsdo not display an illustration and it does not appear on the University’s branding website. If it is not registered, the University would have to rely on unfair competition to prevent further use of this mark.


Longhorns fans displaying Hook 'em Horns
Trademark Law

Under s.32 of the Lanham Act, a trademark is infringed where a person, without the consent of the mark holder, uses the mark in commerce, in a way which is likely to cause confusion. In this case, if referring to the donuts as ‘Longhorns’ makes consumers think the the University has a connection with the donuts, infringement has occurred.

The factors for assessing confusion are set out in Polaroid Corp v Polarad Electronics Corp., 287 F.2d 492 (2d Cir. 1961) and include the strength of the mark, the degree of similarity of the marks, the degree of similarity of the products, the likelihood that the senior user would expand, actual confusion, the defendant’s motive and good faith, the quality of the defendant’s product, the sophistication of the buyer class.

Badge of allegiance or
confusing trademark infringement?
Based on these factors, a finding of confusion is unlikely. Although the ‘Longhorns’ mark is well-know due to the popularity and history of the football team, and the marks are identical, the products are not similar as ‘Longhorns’ is registered for apparel and gourmet foods. It is unlikely that the University would expand into pastries based on the merchandise they currently sell. The donut shop was motivated to make the donut after receiving a request for the Hook ‘em Horns shape from a customer. The donut shop also does other hand gestures such as thumbs up and the peace sign, making it appear that the shop is acting in good faith.

There was no evidence of actual confusion presented by the University, and it is important to note that confusion does not mean call to mind, as set out in University of Notre Dame v J.C Gourmet FoodImports Co., Inc., Appelle, 703 F.2d 1372 (Fed. Cir.. 1983). In that case, University of Notre Dame opposed the registration of ‘Notre Dame’ for cheese. The U.S Court of Appeal held that;

“Likely…to cause confusion” means more than the likelihood that the public will recall a famous mark on seeing the same mark used by another. It must also be established that there is a reasonable basis for the public to attribute the particular product or service of another to the source of the goods or services associated with the famous mark. To hold otherwise would result in recognising a right in gross, which is contrary to the principles of trademark law…”

Consumers who purchase ‘Longhorns donuts’ are more likely to remember their favourite football team than think that the donuts are actually authorised by the university.

Unfair Competition
If the Hook ‘em Horns gesture is not a registered mark, the University would have to rely on unfair competition law under s.43(a) of the Lanham Act to prevent the donut shop from using the hand gesture shape. In order to do this, it would have to be shown that the Hook ‘em Horns gesture is capable of being registered. The mark is likely to be registrable as it does not fall foul of s.2 of the Lanham Act. The only issue may be existing registrations as this hand gesture is also used by fans of rock music, but such registrations are unlikely to cover donuts.

Donut Taco Palace is not looking for a fight
The University would then have to prove there is a likelihood of confusion, using the same Polaroid factors set out above. Again, it is unlikely that the shape of the donuts will result in people being confused as to source, as consumers are probably aware that these donuts are simply a form of allegiance rather than a University authorised product. 

The Donut Taco Palace should be able to sell their ‘Longhorn donuts’ as it is unlikely that they are infringing the University’s trade mark. The shop has changed the name of the donut to ‘El Toro’ but continues to make it in the same shape.  The owner stated, “It wastes time to fight back. It’s not worth it.” Unfortunately for the donut shop, this is a typical example of trademark law being abused by a party in a dominant position to the detriment of a small business owner.





Articles Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry finished we discussed

A few of our information about the Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry, I hope you can exploit carefully

No've You've finished reading an article on Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry and many articles about modern home in our blog this, please read it. and url link of this article is http://liveeconcerts.blogspot.com/2016/09/donut-maker-gored-by-university-of.html Hopefully discussion articles on provide more knowledge about the world of tech gadgets.

Tag : , , , , , , , , , , ,

14 Responses to "Donut maker gored by University of Texas over a fan favourite pastry"

  1. Students have always been the most joyful people, so this was quite predictable. Moreover, now people are able to get assignment help and they have more time for fun. I know that my brother orders essays there sometimes and that's very convenient. I wish it appeared earlier when I was a student.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hello guys. I think students everywhere are tired of home assignments. I know that many of us use a dissertation service. I don't see anything bad in it. I completely understand the situation and I am convinced that it is necessary sometimes

    ReplyDelete
  3. We can deliver any kind of papers you need. Each and every order is covered by experts in a relevant subject’s area. We haven’t made a mistake anywhere.
    Best Services

    ReplyDelete
  4. We provide a lot of convenience to our users and sometimes we offer discounts on rides.
    Baby seat taxi Melbourne

    ReplyDelete
  5. If you need to write the illustration essay, you must know the illustration definition first. If you cannot write an essay yourself, we will do that! Luckily, you have sound the best US writing service with experienced writers and high standards of writing.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Don't know how to submit your essay? Do you have a problem writing it? Take advantage of this https://best-writing-service.com/buy-dissertation-online and you will quickly understand how to do it and it will look great!

    ReplyDelete
  7. she was a young girl, which began as a way to process her innermost thoughts and feelings. Eventually writing took on a life of it’s own: from thoughts and feelings to poems and short stories she put it all on paper at every opportunity.
    The Makings Of Me Book

    ReplyDelete
  8. Hi i,am Selling Various types of Jacket Varsity,Leather,Wool,Fleece with best fitting and better quality. Visit My Website To Order. Thanks
    Superman And Lois Puffer Jacket

    ReplyDelete
  9. Check out our latest products at Real Jackets. The real leather jacket store, men, women, celebrity, halloween and gaming jackets. Explore more to get your favourite product for your wardrobe.
    emily in paris merchandise

    ReplyDelete
  10. Usually I never comment on article but your article is so convincing that I never stop myself to Real Leather Jackets womens say something about it. You’re doing a great job Man,Keep it up.loki jacket

    ReplyDelete
  11. HARDCORE CYCLES was started in the Greater Philadelphia area by a group of tight friends with a passion for V-Twin performance aftermarket parts.Visit our Website Thanks
    SADDLEMEN Step Up Seat Dyna 1996-2003

    ReplyDelete
  12. The key to proving yourself in the field is consistency and perseverance. This blog teaches us how to be a constant and persistent worker in the field.Womens Real Leather Jacket

    ReplyDelete
  13. She began writing as a means to process her innermost thoughts and feelings when she was a little kid. Writing eventually took on a life of its own, and she wrote everything down on paper at every chance, from ideas and feelings to poems and short tales.Satin mens jacket

    ReplyDelete